Federal Asset Forfeiture in Louisiana: How the Government Seizes Property in Criminal Investigations

Federal asset forfeiture is one of the most disruptive tools available to federal investigators and prosecutors in the Eastern District of Louisiana. Through forfeiture, the government can seize cash, vehicles, real estate, bank accounts, and other property alleged to be connected to criminal activity — often before any charges are filed and before any defendant has been convicted. Understanding the different types of federal forfeiture, the procedural rights available to property owners, and the defenses that can be raised is essential for anyone whose property is targeted in a federal investigation.
Civil Versus Criminal Forfeiture
Federal forfeiture takes two principal forms: civil and criminal. Civil forfeiture is an in rem proceeding — it is brought against the property itself rather than against a person. The government files a civil complaint in federal district court naming the property as the defendant (so cases are captioned in the form United States v. $[amount] in United States Currency) and must establish that the property is subject to forfeiture by a preponderance of the evidence. The property owner need not have been charged with any crime, and acquittal in a related criminal case does not automatically preclude civil forfeiture of the same property. Criminal forfeiture, by contrast, is part of the criminal case against a defendant and is imposed as part of a sentence following conviction. The Supreme Court has held that criminal forfeiture is an element of the sentence, not of the offense (Libretti v. United States, 516 U.S. 29 (1995)). Under Rule 32.2 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, after a guilty verdict or plea the court determines whether the required connection between the property and the offense has been established — or, if either party requests it before deliberations, the jury does. Criminal forfeiture cannot proceed against a defendant who is acquitted.
Administrative Forfeiture
A significant category of federal forfeitures never reaches a federal court at all. Administrative (nonjudicial) forfeiture is available for property valued at $500,000 or less, for monetary instruments such as cash regardless of amount, and for certain conveyances used in drug offenses (19 U.S.C. § 1607); it is not available for real property. The seizing agency must send written notice to interested parties as soon as practicable and generally within 60 days of the seizure (18 U.S.C. § 983(a)(1)), and must publish notice. If no one files a timely claim, the property is forfeited without court involvement. The claim deadline is stated in the notice; it may not be earlier than 35 days after the notice is mailed (§ 983(a)(2)(B)).
Filing a timely claim stops the administrative process. Within 90 days after a claim is filed, the government must file a civil forfeiture complaint, obtain an indictment that includes a forfeiture allegation, or return the property, unless the court extends the deadline (§ 983(a)(3)).
How Seizures Begin
Forfeiture in a federal criminal investigation is usually started by the investigating agency — for example the DEA, the FBI, or IRS Criminal Investigation, which is part of the Treasury Department — together with federal prosecutors, who prepare the civil complaint or the forfeiture allegation in the indictment. Seizure often occurs at or around the time of arrest, though the government can also seek a pretrial restraining order. Two Supreme Court decisions limit how far that restraint reaches: the government may not freeze a defendant’s legitimate, untainted assets needed to retain counsel of choice (Luis v. United States, 578 U.S. 5 (2016)), and criminal forfeiture under 21 U.S.C. § 853(a)(1) is limited to property the defendant personally acquired as a result of the crime, without joint and several liability for co-conspirators’ proceeds (Honeycutt v. United States, 581 U.S. 443 (2017)).
Burden of Proof and CAFRA Reforms
Prior to the Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act of 2000 (CAFRA), the burden in federal civil forfeiture proceedings fell on the property owner to prove that the property was not subject to forfeiture. CAFRA shifted the burden to the government in most cases: the government must now establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the property is subject to forfeiture. CAFRA also provided claimants with the right to court-appointed counsel in certain circumstances and made the United States liable for a claimant’s reasonable attorney fees and litigation costs when the claimant substantially prevails in a civil forfeiture case (28 U.S.C. § 2465(b)). While CAFRA was a significant reform, the preponderance standard remains substantially lower than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard applicable to criminal convictions, and many property owners still face the practical difficulty of mounting an expensive civil challenge to forfeiture of modest amounts.
The Innocent Owner Defense
CAFRA codified the innocent owner defense for federal civil forfeiture. An owner who did not know about the conduct giving rise to the forfeiture, or who upon learning of it did all that could reasonably be expected to terminate the illegal use of the property, can assert innocent owner status as a complete defense to forfeiture. Third-party owners — family members, co-owners, lienholders — can raise the innocent owner defense even when the primary user of the property is the target of the investigation. The defense is particularly significant for real property and vehicles where a family member's illegal conduct is alleged to have made the shared asset subject to forfeiture.
Equitable Sharing with State Law Enforcement
Federal forfeiture law includes an equitable sharing program through which federal agencies can transfer a portion of forfeited funds to state and local law enforcement agencies that participated in the investigation. This creates financial incentives for local agencies to work with federal investigators on forfeiture cases, and it allows state agencies to receive forfeiture proceeds that would not be available to them under their own state's forfeiture laws. The equitable sharing program has been the subject of ongoing policy debate regarding its effects on local policing priorities.
Filing a Claim and the Remission Process
Anyone who receives notice of a federal forfeiture has the right to file a claim contesting the forfeiture. In administrative proceedings, the claimant must file within the statutory period specified in the notice; failure to do so results in permanent forfeiture. Once a claim is filed, the proceeding moves to federal court for civil judicial process. Claimants must demonstrate standing — a legal interest in the property — before the government is required to establish the factual basis for forfeiture. Separately from the judicial process, the Department of Justice administers a remission and mitigation process under 28 C.F.R. Part 9 through which individuals who lack a complete legal defense to forfeiture can petition for return of all or part of the seized property on equitable grounds. Remission is a discretionary administrative process and is not a substitute for asserting legal defenses in court. For information on how resolution of criminal charges can affect the associated forfeiture case, see our article on federal plea agreements in the Eastern District of Louisiana.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the government seize property before a criminal conviction?
Yes. Civil forfeiture proceedings are entirely independent of any criminal case, and the government can initiate civil forfeiture without ever charging the property owner with a crime. In criminal cases, the government can seek pretrial restraining orders to freeze assets that might be subject to criminal forfeiture following conviction, within the limits set by Luis. Neither procedure requires a prior conviction.
What is the innocent owner defense and how is it established?
The innocent owner defense, codified in CAFRA, provides a complete defense to civil forfeiture for property owners who either had no knowledge of the illegal use of their property or, upon learning of it, took all reasonable steps to stop that use. The owner bears the burden of proving innocent owner status by a preponderance of the evidence. Family members and third-party owners of real property and vehicles can raise the defense even if the primary illegal user is someone else.
How does the equitable sharing program work?
Under equitable sharing, federal agencies that conduct forfeiture actions can transfer a percentage of the forfeited funds to state and local law enforcement agencies that assisted in the investigation. The amount shared reflects the level of participation by the state agency. State agencies use equitable sharing funds under federal guidelines, and the program creates financial incentives for joint federal-state investigations.
What is the difference between civil forfeiture and criminal forfeiture?
Civil forfeiture is an in rem action against the property itself, can proceed without a criminal conviction, and requires the government to prove forfeiture by a preponderance of the evidence after CAFRA. Criminal forfeiture is imposed as part of a criminal sentence following conviction, is determined by the court (or the jury, on request) under Rule 32.2, and cannot occur if the defendant is acquitted. A defendant who is convicted may face both criminal forfeiture as part of the sentence and separate civil forfeiture actions targeting additional assets.